[Phase 2] HIP-38: Election of Proposers

HIP: 38
title: Election of Proposers
author: @ludoviko, @juanumusic, 0xjean.eth
status: Phase 2
created: 2022-01-26

Simple summary

This HIP establishes that the addresses gathered from the Snapshot poll (later deleted by Snapshot admins but still retrievable through other means) is a legitimate list of candidates for the proposer role, and to establish the addresses of that list should be instated as the initial seed of proposers in the Snapshot platform.

Abstract

HIP-34 established that “Proposers” are comprised of “People elected as proposer through a proposal” (apart from Mission Board Members and others).

This proposal aims to elect the first batch of proposers. A poll made on Snapshot was used to gather a list of addresses of people interested in having that role.

Motivation

Original and deleted proposal was in this link: Snapshot. This is the IPFS link for the proposal (that does not contain the votes): https://ipfs.fleek.co/ipfs/QmbDBvUJNhyaWUu1nhGPSEpuCxqhWP9hwC2FdQuJNM1tVY

As an alternative, this is the IPFS of signed votes for proposers: https://ipfs.io/ipfs/QmYwumh4oS8N6iUvqEEhsJZkaN2DY7dfkcvrNRttzAoUTP?filename=ipfs_signed_proposors.txt. This list was provided by Laurent Genoud, developer and admin of the official Snapshot Telegram group (Telegram: Contact @snapshotlabs).

The poll was used in order to guarantee that proposers belonged to the registry. There was only one option “I offer myself as Proposer”. This document Votes poh.eth WITH LINK - Google Sheets has the IPFS links which show which people voted that option, so they voted in clear knowledge that they offered themselves as proposers.

Implementation

Use the addresses on the list below to grant them the ability to post proposals in the PoH Snapshot pages. (IPFS copy: https://ipfs.io/ipfs/Qmf8Nwezy1gpbtctdHtFPPJFezT6euFcCu5QFUrQYYVu3C?filename=proposoooooooooooooooors.txt )

List:

0x3BE28A28B85c36FB74e513898bC11260Ee541AAC
0xDA35c8e464889bA2Cb91d2E85C608a99D262d5db
bobjiang.eth
0xbeeb01a1E47450479c99b7Eb545D090cDdD78776
0x9d9E26932d012b2Ab21B974fE1552F4025b1e1Cc
poweroverwhelming.eth
18183.eth
0x6Ed3755141cecB387FCB2Ad18b537bc7F2bD524b
0xkafo.eth
0x31452B884F5269eD21e2BAB44CC6A9d48eAac85f
0x6E9A88971e957Abb41bAe4E2677caE258F0c1e76
zrowgz.eth
bosco.eth
0xe724C1D534284f2837F3ab310eF8329BBD7c045E
0xae55D42e157E35a075BA38De7E871178648D2d30
0x342f5be7578CA67506a31214D93a99e5504256CC
0x5886f65425cad457776d7a89a399907c97e608e5
0x85c2043C36be1b84A789E92c29ee3e918ddF50f4
0x275203A89ACEEdee0D07aF626830baE536b36eD1
erik.bjareholt.eth
0xcBCA1f03D67472A7bEe257798Fc93c7eC6c5BE77
0x96925d8E33AE06F6fC9F185F106C6F026d36B352
0xBfF6800aF73a36a7b1821Cc9f18DB00cA4Aa4b3d
0xb0CC32190a06f4bA13027E7D6C516217b49E8eb0
0xe17aE4Ee9f37524d2a25177C8a6C95e51DD85262
0x6bFadF56F24583A777020F6B6EEb11591D79270c
0xcdf2bc5eAE545953A840457eCDCd5a5Bd4466f66
0xb8F6b7dfCA935D1aDB58ab18177F5B72a939Ba70
0x87EE3c1Fb15eae5b9965493C2020dbd3AdACdAfA
0x87EE3c1Fb15eae5b9965493C2020dbd3AdACdAfA
0xcb68A8138c1e57691574670f435A36dB5eCC8E2a
0x39Df2B98daDA52248309770B530c2D2ED0908Cd3
0x670F6eFC8DBA20BBb1BF49bad31845e47216BFF9
0x6c97785edAf8f949a353fcc1629d48759B12F323
0x6c97785edAf8f949a353fcc1629d48759B12F323
0xc0086412BA221bd43e69852c9eA38336D6310885
0xe17aE4Ee9f37524d2a25177C8a6C95e51DD85262
0x7b694B2a461E58b0673565fB8B1D83E962Ed70f3
dacastillo.eth
charles53300.sismo.eth
0xC17671afEc156398D65ffCBD37ea2B3C12225684
0xC17671afEc156398D65ffCBD37ea2B3C12225684
shotaro.eth
0xA72ef9BB82d59464eAA63f461C273f8028b20f5c
0xa697c106f153ba7Fa3801bA2afd6273559c7b105
0x6E9A88971e957Abb41bAe4E2677caE258F0c1e76
0x6E9A88971e957Abb41bAe4E2677caE258F0c1e76
0x364144a07f23EF285DF585D3E4239Ca7B1102535
0xcd3c6214dd023eEA574410FfF03d3c065dc560F3
nicobilinkis.eth
0xE30827AE68533e7a01Fb8369d5219f18D5f70e87
0x3BE28A28B85c36FB74e513898bC11260Ee541AAC
matiasben.eth
jfdominguez.eth
0x8BF7Cd4aE85F765a06006802e21bbCC968f45421
0x14f284988198bBD305C44b7BEA8748323fBB8419
0x0827ED3a46c9793005e4D68E838DE577Cd8DD752
0xb3ca2de6af06BF736c609F3e4dD1307570a37732
0xb3ca2de6af06BF736c609F3e4dD1307570a37732
0x5CfA0c362DADEa86478d05767ed800dd1B026749
0x26D06ec9a2dd19cb33398a58f75d9Aa61dda11cD
v4len.eth
0x61E067aF897a0a9130e5Fbb9bF089223FCa10820
0x6F772F596bB0e9e534Ac99D782eE36578dd15B14
drlorente97.eth
ludoviko.eth
0xmanu.eth
juanu.eth
0xjean.eth
2 Likes

@santisiri @clesaege Can I ask to any of you to review the proposal, and post it on Snapshot if it’s valid?

Thanks in advance!

I don’t see any issue with the proposal and seems compliant with HIP 5 and HIP 34. In order to be more explicit, I would directly include the list of addresses into it since the Google Docs document could be modified any time.

Something like this should work:

0x3BE28A28B85c36FB74e513898bC11260Ee541AAC
0xDA35c8e464889bA2Cb91d2E85C608a99D262d5db
0x521aacB43d89E1b8FFD64d9eF76B0a1074dEdaF8
0xbeeb01a1E47450479c99b7Eb545D090cDdD78776
0x9d9E26932d012b2Ab21B974fE1552F4025b1e1Cc
0x7Bd0faFe34a8B64AfAf16166d644CDbB2B950aaB
0x2B1C66f6d779B6da734d67255be2C54dB2E18977
0x6Ed3755141cecB387FCB2Ad18b537bc7F2bD524b
0x31331EC182777B3E3CF127F4709A8AAa8F76E549
0x31452B884F5269eD21e2BAB44CC6A9d48eAac85f
0x6E9A88971e957Abb41bAe4E2677caE258F0c1e76
0xc0e2324817EaefD075aF9f9fAF52FFaef45d0c04
0x30C7F4F7504D6366916f669cd8E731ED4dF6C702
0xe724C1D534284f2837F3ab310eF8329BBD7c045E
0xae55D42e157E35a075BA38De7E871178648D2d30
0x342f5be7578CA67506a31214D93a99e5504256CC
0x5886f65425cad457776d7a89a399907c97e608e5
0x85c2043C36be1b84A789E92c29ee3e918ddF50f4
0x275203A89ACEEdee0D07aF626830baE536b36eD1
0xBC5eC594509eD050F4A53eEe85D92aF6d2529b56
0xcBCA1f03D67472A7bEe257798Fc93c7eC6c5BE77
0x96925d8E33AE06F6fC9F185F106C6F026d36B352
0xBfF6800aF73a36a7b1821Cc9f18DB00cA4Aa4b3d
0xb0CC32190a06f4bA13027E7D6C516217b49E8eb0
0xe17aE4Ee9f37524d2a25177C8a6C95e51DD85262
0x6bFadF56F24583A777020F6B6EEb11591D79270c
0xcdf2bc5eAE545953A840457eCDCd5a5Bd4466f66
0xb8F6b7dfCA935D1aDB58ab18177F5B72a939Ba70
0x87EE3c1Fb15eae5b9965493C2020dbd3AdACdAfA
0x87EE3c1Fb15eae5b9965493C2020dbd3AdACdAfA
0xcb68A8138c1e57691574670f435A36dB5eCC8E2a
0x39Df2B98daDA52248309770B530c2D2ED0908Cd3
0x670F6eFC8DBA20BBb1BF49bad31845e47216BFF9
0x6c97785edAf8f949a353fcc1629d48759B12F323
0x6c97785edAf8f949a353fcc1629d48759B12F323
0xc0086412BA221bd43e69852c9eA38336D6310885
0xe17aE4Ee9f37524d2a25177C8a6C95e51DD85262
0x7b694B2a461E58b0673565fB8B1D83E962Ed70f3
0xf28AB805D6Edee246443AC25E3C4aA4A2B56c586
0x58805f572924b83b8c224184d2Cf60ad3302DBDF
0xC17671afEc156398D65ffCBD37ea2B3C12225684
0xC17671afEc156398D65ffCBD37ea2B3C12225684
0xE7f13052Fe2bA7D038dac18De5e730542e3979bC
0xA72ef9BB82d59464eAA63f461C273f8028b20f5c
0xa697c106f153ba7Fa3801bA2afd6273559c7b105
0x6E9A88971e957Abb41bAe4E2677caE258F0c1e76
0x6E9A88971e957Abb41bAe4E2677caE258F0c1e76
0x364144a07f23EF285DF585D3E4239Ca7B1102535
0xcd3c6214dd023eEA574410FfF03d3c065dc560F3
0x17a91203A9E9C3519c2F76210497eF7F4BE2352F
0xE30827AE68533e7a01Fb8369d5219f18D5f70e87
0x3BE28A28B85c36FB74e513898bC11260Ee541AAC
0x6D8b0d39053cC84F072E39eF2Aa353Ceef26c295
0xC97C5931C53223B434b64B44d03f4d5B404126b1
0x8BF7Cd4aE85F765a06006802e21bbCC968f45421
0x14f284988198bBD305C44b7BEA8748323fBB8419
0x0827ED3a46c9793005e4D68E838DE577Cd8DD752
0xb3ca2de6af06BF736c609F3e4dD1307570a37732
0xb3ca2de6af06BF736c609F3e4dD1307570a37732
0x5CfA0c362DADEa86478d05767ed800dd1B026749
0x26D06ec9a2dd19cb33398a58f75d9Aa61dda11cD
0x6986E8C8Da33753443959690c240B03931Bd1Edc
0x61E067aF897a0a9130e5Fbb9bF089223FCa10820
0x6F772F596bB0e9e534Ac99D782eE36578dd15B14
0x816384B4E6644f3A1Cb683E1CB83409A464532eA
0x504E7620069a0a8354434dED3150ed7E2ECF5153
0x482C96b007EA453cb55A3DC11ceB8830e18F0639
0x2ad91063e489CC4009DF7feE45C25c8BE684Cf6a
0x6687c671980E65ebD722b9146Fc61e2471558dd6

Thanks Santi! I’ve edited the proposal, added the list of addresses and removed the redundant Google Sheets link.

Let us know if you encounter any issues with character limits! In that case we can rely on the the IPFS link.

1 Like

The only other observation is that, for greater clarity for voters, if any of those addresses has an ENS domain, it would be good to see it that way also.

There you go

0x3BE28A28B85c36FB74e513898bC11260Ee541AAC
0xDA35c8e464889bA2Cb91d2E85C608a99D262d5db
bobjiang.eth
0xbeeb01a1E47450479c99b7Eb545D090cDdD78776
0x9d9E26932d012b2Ab21B974fE1552F4025b1e1Cc
poweroverwhelming.eth
18183.eth
0x6Ed3755141cecB387FCB2Ad18b537bc7F2bD524b
0xkafo.eth
0x31452B884F5269eD21e2BAB44CC6A9d48eAac85f
0x6E9A88971e957Abb41bAe4E2677caE258F0c1e76
zrowgz.eth
bosco.eth
0xe724C1D534284f2837F3ab310eF8329BBD7c045E
0xae55D42e157E35a075BA38De7E871178648D2d30
0x342f5be7578CA67506a31214D93a99e5504256CC
0x5886f65425cad457776d7a89a399907c97e608e5
0x85c2043C36be1b84A789E92c29ee3e918ddF50f4
0x275203A89ACEEdee0D07aF626830baE536b36eD1
erik.bjareholt.eth
0xcBCA1f03D67472A7bEe257798Fc93c7eC6c5BE77
0x96925d8E33AE06F6fC9F185F106C6F026d36B352
0xBfF6800aF73a36a7b1821Cc9f18DB00cA4Aa4b3d
0xb0CC32190a06f4bA13027E7D6C516217b49E8eb0
0xe17aE4Ee9f37524d2a25177C8a6C95e51DD85262
0x6bFadF56F24583A777020F6B6EEb11591D79270c
0xcdf2bc5eAE545953A840457eCDCd5a5Bd4466f66
0xb8F6b7dfCA935D1aDB58ab18177F5B72a939Ba70
0x87EE3c1Fb15eae5b9965493C2020dbd3AdACdAfA
0x87EE3c1Fb15eae5b9965493C2020dbd3AdACdAfA
0xcb68A8138c1e57691574670f435A36dB5eCC8E2a
0x39Df2B98daDA52248309770B530c2D2ED0908Cd3
0x670F6eFC8DBA20BBb1BF49bad31845e47216BFF9
0x6c97785edAf8f949a353fcc1629d48759B12F323
0x6c97785edAf8f949a353fcc1629d48759B12F323
0xc0086412BA221bd43e69852c9eA38336D6310885
0xe17aE4Ee9f37524d2a25177C8a6C95e51DD85262
0x7b694B2a461E58b0673565fB8B1D83E962Ed70f3
dacastillo.eth
charles53300.sismo.eth
0xC17671afEc156398D65ffCBD37ea2B3C12225684
0xC17671afEc156398D65ffCBD37ea2B3C12225684
shotaro.eth
0xA72ef9BB82d59464eAA63f461C273f8028b20f5c
0xa697c106f153ba7Fa3801bA2afd6273559c7b105
0x6E9A88971e957Abb41bAe4E2677caE258F0c1e76
0x6E9A88971e957Abb41bAe4E2677caE258F0c1e76
0x364144a07f23EF285DF585D3E4239Ca7B1102535
0xcd3c6214dd023eEA574410FfF03d3c065dc560F3
nicobilinkis.eth
0xE30827AE68533e7a01Fb8369d5219f18D5f70e87
0x3BE28A28B85c36FB74e513898bC11260Ee541AAC
matiasben.eth
jfdominguez.eth
0x8BF7Cd4aE85F765a06006802e21bbCC968f45421
0x14f284988198bBD305C44b7BEA8748323fBB8419
0x0827ED3a46c9793005e4D68E838DE577Cd8DD752
0xb3ca2de6af06BF736c609F3e4dD1307570a37732
0xb3ca2de6af06BF736c609F3e4dD1307570a37732
0x5CfA0c362DADEa86478d05767ed800dd1B026749
0x26D06ec9a2dd19cb33398a58f75d9Aa61dda11cD
v4len.eth
0x61E067aF897a0a9130e5Fbb9bF089223FCa10820
0x6F772F596bB0e9e534Ac99D782eE36578dd15B14
drlorente97.eth
ludoviko.eth
0xmanu.eth
juanu.eth
0xjean.eth
1 Like

Hey Santi! We’ve updated the list to include the ENS names.

1 Like

Where is nachobr.eth there?

It’s not in it because the list only includes people that “voted” in the poll that we used to gather addresses. Ask @santisiri or @clesaege, they are able to delegate according to HIP-34.

2 Likes

Published Phase 2 vote: Snapshot

3 Likes

This vote has been approved and has now been moved to Phase 3 binding vote: Snapshot