[Phase-3] HIP-16: Make admin roles of communication platforms eligible

[0xjean.eth]

@ludovico

Each time one of the official Administrators lose their position on Tokenlog’s ranking, the next candidate to come up in the rank will gain the official role as Administrator.

• Do you expect the elected admins to change frequently because they are voted in and out?
• What happens when an admin changes position in the ranking during a heated debate?
• Wouldn’t this generate a constant “voting pressure” that may lead to fatigue, with the main difference that it occurs outside Snapshot?

Wouldn’t it be better to establish a time period for re-evaluating who are the admins? Example: every Monday at 12PM. First day of every Month.

Is it possible to implement the ability to retract votes on tokenlog?

If there is a constant election going, it’s possible we will change our opinion, after having spent all votes. If we encourage being extra mindful about voting, then we might be rewarding users that do not think long-term and may use all their voting power to attack the system.

@ludovico

Admins revoked in this way cannot re-apply for the role in the next term.

If I understand correctly, there is no “term”, right?

@ludovico

Roles are only revocable for security reasons or serious offenses to the community. The Mission Board can call an emergency voting of 24h in Snapshot

Isn’t waiting 24h too much if there’s a clear attack on the group?

I would have liked to include the ability to remove admins if they are inactive as well.