[Phase 2] HIP-75: Remove the Mission Board Member Role

HIP: 75
Title: Remove the Mission Board Member Role 
Authors: asobol.eth, berty.eth, AnM, lucianovarela.eth, monik74.eth, gian1uca.eth, onediss.eth, fukenio.eth, forer.eth, nicod.eth, tomasmika.eth, nicolira.eth, l18630.eth
Status: Phase 2
Created: 2022-10-31

Simple Summary

This HIP aims to remove the figure of Mission Board Member as it currently exists and to terminate the functions of the current members of the Mission Board.

Abstract

The role of Mission Board Member will be terminated. All tasks that are assigned to the Mission Board Members will cease to be their responsibility. The current Mission Board Members Board Santi.eth, 0xjean.eth, nix.eth (Justin Kalland) and V4len.eth, as well as the currently vacant fifth seat will cease to function due to the elimination of the position they held.

Motivation

The role of Mission Board Member has so far only caused a rift in the community, delaying the normal development of the organization. Several of its members embarrassed the community with their public manifestations, others were not present except on rare occasions. Most of the functions assigned to them have not been executed. “Personalisms” only proved to generate a war of egos that discredits us in front of the rest of the ecosystem.

Specification

The Mission Board will cease to be a representative figure of this DAO. The functions of its members will cease to be its responsibility.

Rationale

Ongoing developments proved that the MB produces enormous political cost, for dubious benefit. Moreover, HIPs have proven to be a way to remove MB members, despite being democratically elected.

The only practical purpose of the MB is being able to correct small mistakes, under specific circumstances, anything else requiring HIP amendments. This benefit doesn’t warrant the cost.

Implementation

Upon approval of phase 3 of this proposal, the role of the Mission Board will be eliminated and its members will cease to be recognized and representative figures for Proof of Humanity.
The responsibilities that are currently assigned to them will be decided democratically through the Snapshot platform.

(Traducción al español)

Simple Summary

Esta HIP pretende remover la figura de Mission Board Member tal como existe en la actualidad y dar el cese de funciones a los actuales miembros de la junta de misión.

Abstract

Se dará cese al rol de Mission Board Member. Todas las tareas que estén adjudicadas a los miembros de la junta de misión dejarán de ser su responsabilidad. Los actuales miembros de la Junta de Misión Board Santi.eth, 0xjean.eth, nix.eth (Justin Kalland) y V4len.eth, además del quinto asiento actualmente vacante cesarán en sus funciones debido a la eliminación del puesto que ostentaban.

Motivation

El rol de Mission Board Member hasta el momento solo provocó una grieta en la comunidad, retrasando el normal desarrollo de la organización. Varios de sus miembros avergonzaron a esta comunidad con sus manifestaciones publicas, otros no estuvieron presentes salvo en contadas ocasiones. La mayoria de las funciones que les fueron asignadas no se han ejecutado. Los personalismos solo demostraron generar una guerra de egos que nos desprestigia ante el resto del ecosistema.

Specification

La junta de Misión dejará de ser una figura representativa de esta DAO. Las funciones de sus miembros dejaran de ser su responsabilidad.

Rationale

Los acontecimientos en curso han demostrado que el MB produce un enorme coste político, a cambio de un dudoso beneficio. Además, los HIP han demostrado ser una forma de destituir a los miembros del MB, a pesar de haber sido elegidos democráticamente.

El único propósito práctico del MB es poder corregir pequeños errores, en circunstancias específicas, cualquier otra cosa que requiera enmiendas del HIP. Este beneficio no justifica el coste.

Implementation

Al momento de aprobarse la fase 3 de esta propuesta se eliminará el rol de Junta de Misión y sus miembros dejarán de ser figuras reconocidas y representativas para Proof of Humanity.
Las responsabilidades que hasta el momento se les adjudican seran dirimidas de manera democratica a través de la plataforma snapshot.

2 Likes

Invalid and rushed proposal, absolutely no feedback from the DAO.

There was plenty of discussion in this thread posted on September 11, including posts by @clesaege and
@santisiri.

This was also discussed on Telegram groups, both public and private.

4 Likes